Church name: St. Sabina
Church address: 3827 W Ogden Chicago, IL 60623
Date attended: September 14
Church category: Different ethnicity
Describe the worship service you attended. How was it similar to or different from your regular context?
St. Sabina is best described as Mass-meets-the-Tony-award-winning-Broadway-musical-Cats. Smatterings of liturgy punctuated 2 hours and 45 minutes of elaborate singing, instrumentals, and choreographed dancing. One song, “The Sound of Heaven Touching Earth,” was performed with such enthusiasm and pomp that it lived up to its title. The church takes on the task of being both Catholic and charismatic, forming a sub-denomination that seems to be primarily based on the firey personality of Father Pfleger. He reminded me more of a Pentecostal preacher rather than my idea of a more reserved Catholic priest. He spoke loudly, with dramatic language and exaggerated gestures. His enthusiasm definitely matched the spirit of his congregation. The entire service unfolded before us like a theatrical performance. The only way the worship service compares to my past church experience through its liturgical structure. But the liturgy was quite loose and only served to keep me somewhat aware of my place in the order of service.
What did you find most interesting or appealing about the worship service?
St. Sabina was fascinating. I am still astounded by the music, which was much more than I would ever expect a mid-sized church to pull off, or really any church for that matter. I appreciate that they take the time to invest in music and the visual arts, and I liked that they incorporated more than one way to worship God. I also really admire the social justice mission of St. Sabina. The church is not afraid to blatantly stand against gun violence in their neighborhood. They have peace marches, protest the unregulated sale of guns, and advocate politically. Father Pfleger mentioned in his sermon that the new Catholic bishop of Chicago pointed to St. Sabina as a model for church engagement against violence in the community, as the effects of the movement are felt citywide. Gun laws and violence are something that the American church seems to be quiet about as a whole, so it’s refreshing to see a church reaching towards justice. St. Sabina also offers a lot of great social services programs, like a food pantry and a job training service that I actually recommended some of my tenants to at my internship.
What did you find most disorienting or challenging about the worship service?
I am not entirely convinced that St. Sabina isn’t a cult, especially because Father Pfleger had to explicitly tell us that they aren’t a cult. Father Pfleger reminded me of a liberal Mark Driscoll, except with passion for social justice and less plagiarism. When I told my supervisor at my internship that I attended St. Sabina, he mentioned that he belonged to the church for 8 months but left because Pfleger is an “egomaniac.” My supervisor said that the Catholic church in Chicago is worried about what will happen when Pfleger steps down after his 30+ years in office because no one is being groomed to take over the congregation, and the church is so rooted in the personality of Pfleger. While I cannot verify any of these claims from my single Sunday at St. Sabian, I would not be surprised if this was accurate. Pfleger seems to thrive on controversy for the sake of controversy. He spoke often of the media attention that he is getting in his sermon and referred to St. Sabina’s work as his own rather than the congregations. I found the role he takes as a priest especially interesting when comparing him to Coach at Lawndale. Both men are white pastors of about 30 years to a mainly African American church body. They both deeply care about social justice and the flourishing of their communities. Yet their personalities and leadership styles are polar opposites. I tend to prefer the humbler, quieter leadership of Coach, although I affirm the strong social values and good work that is happening at St. Sabina.
What aspects of Scripture or theology did the worship service illuminate for you that you had not perceived as clearly in your regular context?
In Father Pfleger’s sermon, he spoke about God’s justice and the dangers of being a church of fear. He said that God’s justice is not like human justice because it is so deeply rooted in mercy. The context of St. Sabina is much different than my own. The neighborhood of Auburn Gresham is much more segregated and less diverse than my usual context, as it is 97.78% African American. The struggles of this neighborhood do not match my own, and living in fear does mean the same for me as it does to St. Sabina’s congregation. Hearing a message of justice preached in a context where the effects of injustice are so immediate took on a more powerful and tangible meaning.